99 Points, Decanter
“This is an exemplary coastal Pinot Noir. Scallop Shelf is an estate cuvée selected by winemaker Vanessa Wong. The driver is Pommard clone selection (60%), which lends to blood orange and pomegranate pulp. It’s the most aromatic, elegant and finesse-driven of the Peay wines—savoury notes of pine needles, briny sea air and bright evergreen bough aromatics. The palate is delicate, with freshness, depth and finesse all coming together. The texture is lush and silky; bright acids lift the blue and red fruits. Dried mountain herbs create a framework for floral and umami elements, with smoky sea salt minerality lifting the finish.”
97 Points, Wine Enthusiast
“Beautifully delineated aromas of crushed cherry, earthy mushroom, dried sage and violets mingle on the nose of this elegant and complex Pinot. The palate leans into the cool climate character of the vineyard with focused flavors of dried blackberry, dark cocoa, Darjeeling and nori, while rich tannin and energetic acidity balance on a razor’s edge. While lovely now, this will age beautifully for a decade or more.”
97 Points, Jeb Dunnuck
“A medium ruby red hue, the 2022 Pinot Noir Scallop Shelf is fantastic and layered with notes of violets, crushed stones, black raspberries, wild herbs, and a hint of pepper spice. Medium-bodied, it offers a long, incredible texture all the way through, with a velvety sea foam feel and a clean finish. Drink over the next 15 or so years.”
96 Points, Vinous
“The 2022 Pinot Noir Scallop Shelf offers a more linear, mineral-driven expression of the estate. Most of this fruit is Pommard clone, but that is not especially evident. Red-toned fruit, chalk, mint, white pepper and slate lend brightness. This linear, focused Pinot bristles with saline energy and tension. Give it time.”